Gil’s Musings

The Municipal Yield Game

The relative attractiveness of Municipal bonds continues to astound me. With Treasury yields dropping precipitously, tax-free municipal yields seem the hands-down winner of the yield game. Much of this is due to large foreign players elbowing their way into the US Treasury market to hide from worldwide financial turmoil. They have bid prices up accordingly on the bond market’s most liquid vehicles- Treasuries. These buyers would not benefit from the tax-free nature of muni yields, and the muni market is far too fragmented and illiquid for the trillions of dollars that are rolling around looking for a home. But this creates interest rate nirvana for retail investors looking for a nominal return with nominal risks. While the muni market is considered liquid, it is very much an “art trader’s market”. The muni market is filled with $50,000 and $100,000 pieces for sale, so bidding in $100 Million chunks is completely out of the question. Accordingly, institutional buyers are mostly absent, except for mutual funds. Normally, tax-free munis yield about 80% of Treasuries. With no Federal taxes due on muni coupons, the lower return makes the choice between munis and Treasuries a near wash. This slightly favoring the muni, since most buyers are in a 35% tax bracket, not 20%. This is what makes President Obama’s proposal six-months ago to tax wealthy investor’s returns on munis such a joke. This would not have the effect he was desiring, since it would serve to crush the market value of existing bonds, and drive up the borrowing costs for every municipal bond issuer as they would be forced to fill the tax gap with yield, not with Joe Fat Cat wealthy investor simply writing a bigger check to Uncle Sam. Furthermore, the 100-year-old sacrosanct tax-favored status for municipalities would be forever shaken. He obviously did not think that one through.

So to put the current advantages in perspective, let’s look at current yields. Since January of this year, ten-year muni yields have dropped from 2.4% to 2.1%, and thirty-year yields have dropped from 4.35% to 4.15%. During that same time frame, 10-year Treasury yields have dropped from 2.3% to 1.6%, and thirty-year rates from 3.45% to 2.7%.

Segment Wealth Management Investment Yield Chart

That means a 30-year muni yields 1.5 times what the 30-year Treasury yields, before you consider the muni interest is also tax-free! In a 35% tax bracket, the Treasury actually yields 1.76%. That means the muni outruns the Treasury by 2.5 to 1 after tax! Consider too that munis can also be compared to corporate bonds, where a similar disparity exists. But considering that most munis are backed up by taxation of some sort, the historical default rate on an “A” rated muni is forty-times lower than an “A” rated corporate bond.

Segment Wealth Management After Tax Yields Chart

While the future at some point likely holds a rising rate environment, that painful scenario would seemingly put less pressure on muni prices than on Treasuries, given that Treasuries have won the rising price game hands-down to this point.

Please see IMPORTANT DISCLOSURE information

Subscribe to Gil’s Musings

Sign up to receive Gil’s periodic musings about investment trends, the stock market, investor behavior and current affairs. Join today and receive a handful of Gil’s favorite past musings, and be the first to receive his freshly penned thoughts

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.